The Wife Upstairs Review: A Twisty Modern Gothic About Greed, Secrets, and Second Chances
The Wife Upstairs Review: My Thoughts
The Wife Upstairs Review: What Worked For Me
In this The Wife Upstairs review, I’m sharing my thoughts on Rachel Hawkins’ modern retelling of Jane Eyre—a psychological thriller filled with secrets, deception, and morally gray characters.
There were moments in the middle where I felt a little confused, but after finishing the book and reflecting on it, I realized that was entirely the point. Rachel Hawkins slowly reveals information through layered perspectives, keeping readers slightly off-balance without ever becoming completely lost. Looking back, I actually appreciated that approach because it made the final pieces click together naturally.
At the beginning, I wasn’t particularly fond of Jane. I have a hard time rooting for characters who intentionally pursue wealthy partners for financial security, so it took me a while to warm up to her. But as the story unfolded, I realized Jane wasn’t the only person driven by money.
If anything, Eddie turned out to be the true opportunist.
What makes the novel interesting is how almost every major decision is motivated by wealth, status, or the desire for security. No one is entirely innocent, and watching each character justify their choices made the story far more compelling than I expected.
The pacing also kept me engaged. Even when I guessed one of the major twists ahead of time, it didn’t lessen my enjoyment because I still wanted to see how everything would unfold.
The Wife Upstairs Review: Why It Didn’t Fully Click
My biggest challenge was the middle section of the novel.
There were times when I had to pause and think about what was happening because the shifting perspectives and gradual reveals made certain scenes feel intentionally disorienting. While I understand why the story was structured this way, it occasionally slowed my reading experience.
I also predicted one of the larger twists before it happened. Thankfully, the suspense doesn’t rely entirely on shocking reveals. The novel remains entertaining because of its characters, the growing tension, and the constant uncertainty surrounding everyone’s true motives.
Final Thoughts on The Wife Upstairs
The Wife Upstairs is less about surprising twists and more about the dangerous things people convince themselves are justified in pursuit of money, security, and power.
The modern Jane Eyre inspiration adds another layer of intrigue without requiring readers to be familiar with the classic novel. While the mystery didn’t completely catch me off guard, I still found the journey worthwhile, and the ending felt like the right conclusion for these characters.
If you enjoy psychological thrillers filled with morally gray characters, family secrets, unreliable motives, and slow-burning suspense, I think The Wife Upstairs is worth picking up.
Book Information
Title: The Wife Upstairs
Author: Rachel Hawkins
Genre: Thriller
Subgenre: Psychological Thriller, Domestic Thriller, Mystery, Gothic Retelling
Page Count: 290 pages
POV: Multiple
Narrative Style: First Person
Series Information: Standalone
Themes and Tropes
- modern Jane Eyre retelling
- morally gray characters
- money and greed
- marriage secrets
- deception and manipulation
Top 3 Highlights
A clever modern retelling. Even without extensive knowledge of Jane Eyre, the story stands well on its own while rewarding readers who recognize the classic inspiration.
Morally gray characters. Almost everyone has questionable motives, making it difficult to fully trust—or completely root for—anyone.
A slow-burning mystery. The gradual reveals keep the tension building until the final chapters, where the pieces finally fall into place.
Gore Level: 2/5
Some violence and murder are described, but nothing excessively graphic.
Spice Level: 2/5
Some sexual content and references.
Profanity: Moderate.
Violence: Murder, manipulation, emotional abuse, deception.
Substances: Alcohol consumption.
Who Should Read The Wife Upstairs?
Readers who enjoy domestic thrillers, morally gray protagonists, unreliable narrators, and modern retellings of classic literature will likely enjoy The Wife Upstairs. If you appreciate stories where character motivations matter just as much as the mystery itself, this one is worth adding to your TBR.
Overall Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
An entertaining psychological thriller with morally gray characters, layered storytelling, and a satisfying ending that proves greed often comes at a price.
Rachel Hawkins delivers a compelling modern gothic thriller where no one is entirely innocent. While I predicted one of the major twists, the layered storytelling, morally complex characters, and themes of greed and deception kept me invested until the very end.
Check out this book review on my Bookstagram.
See my bookshelves on Goodreads.
More Reviews You Might Enjoy
If you liked this review, check out:
Dear Debbie by Freida McFadden
Be the first to comment